Monday, March 21, 2011

Martin Bashir Interviews Rob Bell. Paul Edwards Interviews Martin Bashir about the Interview of Rob Bell.

I posted the following interview on my Facebook page last week, but since I was out of town I did not take time to post it here. Frankly, I was amazed at the forthrightness of Martin Bashir. I encourage you to take a few moments to hear Bashir's questions and Bell's responses. Then, I encourage you to take the time to listen to Paul Edwards' interview of Martin Bashir here.

Martin Bashir’s Superb Interview of Rob Bell

Perhaps you have wondered, as I, whether Martin Bashir is an evangelical Christian. It was not only Bashir's knowledge of the issues that struck me but also his evident passion to get to the truth of the matter. Yesterday, while in New York City we attended Redeemer Presbyterian Church (at 2 West 64th Street, NYC) we noticed an announcement of an upcoming event next Monday concerning a conversation between Tim Keller and Martin Bashir (see here). This prompted a thought. I wondered whether Martin Bashir attends Redeemer Presbyterian Church. So, after returning home, today I did a little research that confirmed my hunch. Bashir does, in fact, attend Redeemer and he is an evangelical believer. However, listen to the full interview below to hear Bashir’s explanation of why he interviewed Bell as he did. He is interested in the truth.

MSNBC’s Martin Bashir on The Paul Edwards Program

Mar 17, 2011 by Paul Edwards


Here’s the audio of my interview with MSNBC’s Martin Bashir on his interview with Emergent Universalist Rob Bell of Mars Hill Church in Grand Rapids. Martin discloses whether or not he is a committed Christian and if the blog rumors are true that he attends Tim Keller’s Redeemer Presbyterian Church in New York City.
Listen to the interview here.
You may listen to or download the interview here.

7 comments:

Ben Vos said...

Is Bashir interested in the truth? Or is he interested in control and certainty, which in truth are inaccessible to fallible, sinful human beings this side of eternity?

A. B. Caneday said...

Did you listen to the interview Paul Edwards engages with Martin Bashir? He claims he is interested in the truth.

Let's ponder your second question, which actually makes an assertion, a truth-claim.

You wonder, "Or is he interested in control and certainty, which in truth are inaccessible to fallible, sinful human beings this side of eternity?"

First, Bashir did not claim to be on a quest for certainty; his pursuit is truth. But, I will assume that you are using truth and certainty interchangeably, given your the nature of your two questions.

Second, do you not recognize that you have asserted that you know the truth with certainty which is the very thing that you deny that Martin Bashir can know? If it is not obvious to you, I will attempt to make it clearer for you. You claim that truth is in truth . . . inaccessible to fallible, sinful human beings this side of eternity. Yet by making this statement within your question, you are asserting a truth-claim and doing so with certainty. After all, the phrase, in truth, as you use it, is another way of speaking of certainty. If certainty is in truth . . . inaccessible to you, as you claim, then I am wondering how you can know with certainty that truth is not accessible to you or to anyone else.

Ben, you claim to know truth with certainty while at the same time denying that anyone can know truth with certainty. This is like declaring, "There certainly is no such thing as certain truth." You have made a claim that contradicts your own claim.

Perhaps you alone have access to truth with certainty while the rest of us are poor benighted folks who have no access to truth with any certainty. Of course, you don't really believe what you assert. Do you?

Neither Martin Bashir nor I would claim to know truth exhaustively. No mere human has exhaustive knowledge, for no mere human is deity; God alone has exhaustive knowledge. Nevertheless, we can have true knowledge of truth. Thus, we can be certain in truth to that degree.

Thanks for stopping by.

HuEmanity Unlimited said...

Thanks for posting these interviews. I look forward to viewing them.

HuEmanity Unlimited said...

Just viewed the your video posts and it seems like the interviewer hasn't read the book but rather the critics reviews of the book.
Am I missing something?

A. B. Caneday said...

Yes, HuEmanity, I believe that you are missing something. It is manifestly evident that Bashir did read the book.

Benjamin Paul Virgo said...

A. B., I applaud your responses, above, for their clarity and simplicity.

V best

Ben Virgo

johntindall said...

When I preached in South London in the 1990s Martin Bashir was in the congregation and was an enthusiastic lover of the Gospel.